Ukraine's New Military Strategy Faces Criticism as Shortages Persist

UA
Published:

A leading analyst has expressed concerns over Ukraine's recent military strategy, which aims to establish new brigades to address significant manpower shortages amid ongoing conflict with Russia. Michael Kofman, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, stated that the decision to form new units rather than reinforce existing ones has led to puzzling results.

Kofman highlighted that these newly formed brigades, often lacking experience, have been generally ineffective in combat. He noted that many of their battalions are being reallocated to support established brigades that are struggling to maintain their strength on the front lines. This strategy has resulted in a fragmented defensive effort as troops are spread thin across multiple units.

Ukrainian leadership had aimed to create ten new brigades in 2024, hoping to rotate fresh units into combat. However, reports reveal that many of these new formations are poorly equipped and face high rates of desertion. For instance, the newly established 155th Mechanized Brigade has been criticized for its inability to maintain troop levels and operational effectiveness.

Amidst these challenges, the Ukrainian armed forces said that they have had to revert to domestic production to meet weapon requirements due to insufficient international military aid. In addition, there has been rapid innovation in drone technology, which has provided some tactical advantages, though it is not enough to compensate for the fundamental issues with manpower and training that Ukraine continues to face.

As the conflict drags on, with Russia making incremental gains in the eastern Donbas region, Kofman emphasized the urgent need for Ukraine to address its persistent manpower shortages to sustain its defensive capabilities against the ongoing assault.

Weekly Newsletter

News summary by melangenews

Loading...

More from Ukraine

Intensified Russian Offensive in Eastern Ukraine Amid Drone Activity

Russian forces are continuing their relentless offensive in eastern Ukraine, intensifying pressure on Ukrainian defenders, according to the Ukrainian General Staff. On January 30, they reported 125 Russian attacks, with a significant focus on the city of Pokrowsk in the Donetsk region, where 51 battles occurred the previous day. Pokrowsk, a mining town that had a population of approximately 60,000 before the war, has been a focal point of conflict for months. Reports indicate that Russia is attempting to maneuver south of the city rather than capturing it directly, with only the village of Udatschne remaining unoccupied before reaching Ukrainian territory in Dnipropetrowsk. Additionally, the Russian military blog Rybar claimed that Russian troops have gained control over more parts of the city of Chasiv Yar, although Ukrainian sources have denied the complete fall of the area. Simultaneously, air alerts were triggered in several Ukrainian regions overnight due to the presence of Russian combat drones, while the Russian defense ministry claimed to have intercepted 17 Ukrainian drones over Russia. Meanwhile, the International Atomic Energy Agency reported that its observers at the Russian-occupied Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant hear combat noise almost daily, with several explosions noted nearby.
UA

Ukraine Develops Countermeasure System Against Advanced Russian Drones

Ukraine's Magyar Birds drone unit has reportedly devised an innovative countermeasure system to combat Russian fiber-optic-controlled FPV drones, which are increasingly being used as effective weapons on the battlefield. According to commander Robert Brovdi, the unit utilizes mobile radars to detect incoming drones, allowing them to launch their own drones for interception before the Russian drones can hit their targets. Brovdi shared a video on Telegram showing one of their drones destroying a Russian FPV drone, emphasizing that they have developed functioning options for both detection and destruction. The fiber-optic technology used by the Russian drones, which connects them directly to controllers preventing jamming, has made them particularly formidable. Brovdi has urged for a faster deployment of mobile radar systems along the front lines to improve early warning capabilities against these fast-moving threats. This development highlights the evolving dynamic of drone warfare in the conflict, where both Ukrainian and Russian forces have relied heavily on drones for reconnaissance and attacks since the onset of the war.
UA

Russian Bombing Claims Lives of Three Generations in Zaporizhzhia

In a devastating incident in Zaporizhzhia, Ukraine, a Russian bombing on November 7, 2022, killed three members of a single family: Sophiia Buhayova, 27, her 17-month-old son Adam Buhayov, and Tetiana Tarasevych, 68. According to BBC correspondent Orla Guerin, the family was at home when a guided aerial bomb struck their apartment block, resulting in their deaths and that of six other civilians. Yuliia Tarasevych, Sophiia's mother, expressed her profound grief, stating, "I lost my mother, my daughter, and my grandson in one second." She shared that some of Adam's final moments were filmed by Tetiana as they enjoyed a walk prior to the attack. As the war in Ukraine continues to escalate, Yuliia visited the cemetery where her loved ones are buried, lamenting, "It’s hell on earth." As international focus on the conflict wanes, both Yuliia and her husband Serhiy emphasize the necessity for Ukraine to resist Russian aggression. They fear that any calls for negotiations, especially amid changing political tides, could undermine their fight for sovereignty.
UA
All Ukraine News ->