Human Rights Watch Criticizes Australia’s Treatment of Asylum Seekers and Youth Offenders

AU
Published:

A recent report by Human Rights Watch (HRW) highlights significant concerns regarding Australia's treatment of asylum seekers and youth offenders, describing the situation as "diabolical" and "appalling." The HRW report, which reviews human rights practices in over 100 countries, asserts that Australia is regressing in its handling of vulnerable populations.

The report draws attention to the Northern Territory's decision to reinstate spit hoods for youth detainees and the ongoing practice of detaining children in watch houses in Queensland. It cites alarming findings, including footage of children in isolation cells struggling to breathe. The Queensland government's enactment of laws labeling "adult crime, adult time" has further exacerbated these issues, increasing maximum sentences for youth offenders despite acknowledging violations against international and state human rights standards.

HRW's Australia director, Daniela Gavshon, argues that these developments represent a negligent disregard for international norms. The report also criticizes Australia’s treatment of asylum seekers, particularly those transferred to detention facilities on Nauru, many of whom have had their communications restricted. Despite the federal government's recent legislative changes allowing payments to third countries for accepting non-citizens, the report emphasizes that Australia continues to evade its international obligations regarding asylum seekers.

As Australia approaches a federal election, Gavshon warns against political rhetoric that demonizes asylum seekers and refugees, urging the public to remember their humanity. The report raises alarm over the implications these practices hold not only for Australia but also as a precedent for other nations.

Weekly Newsletter

News summary by melangenews

Loading...

More from Australia

Google Faces Class-Action Lawsuits from Australian Publishers Over Ad Revenue Claims

Google is currently embroiled in two class-action lawsuits in Australia, with publishers alleging that the tech giant is abusing its dominant position in the digital advertising market, thus adversely affecting their advertising revenue. The claims were presented in a federal court in Melbourne on January 31, 2025, with law firm Piper Alderman representing publications such as LGBTQ+ outlet QNews. One regional newspaper, Riverine Grazier, reported that its ad earnings from Google have dwindled to as low as $20 per month. The lawsuits assert that Google's practices have resulted in unfairly reduced ad revenue for publishers. An Australian Competition and Consumer Commission report indicated that Google significantly influences the ad tech supply chain, often taking up to a 27% cut from ad sales. In response, Google contends that the accusations overlook the competitive nature of the advertising market, arguing that its tools help support publishers and businesses alike. The next court hearing is scheduled for March 4, 2025.
AU

Man Acquitted of Rape Charges Due to 'Sexsomnia' Defense in Sydney Court

Timothy Malcolm Rowland, a 40-year-old man diagnosed with "sexsomnia," was acquitted of raping a woman in his Sydney apartment in August 2022. Rowland had claimed that he was experiencing a medical episode characterized by sexual behavior during sleep at the time of the incident. The jury reached the not guilty verdict after a seven-day trial, during which Judge John Pickering emphasized that the court should not determine criminal liability based on actions performed while unconscious. The case stemmed from an evening where Rowland and the woman spent time together before returning to his apartment. Following their night out, the woman fell asleep in Rowland's bed, and she alleged that she awoke to find him engaging in sexual activity without her consent. While the woman's sleep was undisputed, the central issue for the jury was whether Rowland was genuinely unaware of his actions due to his condition at the time. Judge Pickering cautioned the jurors against creating laws regarding unconscious actions and urged them to focus solely on the evidence presented in court.
AU

Queensland's Ban on Puberty Blockers Sparks Controversy Over Youth Health

The Queensland government has announced a ban on puberty blockers for new patients at the state's only gender clinic, a move criticized as "discriminatory" by LGBTQI advocates and health officials. Anna Cody, Australia's sex discrimination commissioner, warned that the decision could harm the physical and mental wellbeing of children seeking gender-affirming care, stating it may create trauma for those awaiting treatment. Health Minister Tim Nicholls explained that the ban will remain until an independent review of puberty blockers and hormone therapy is completed, prompted by concerns over inadequate medical support at the Cairns Sexual Health Service. The local health authority confirmed an internal review identified "process issues" but found no evidence of patient harm. Rachel Hines, CEO of Open Doors Youth Service, echoed concerns, highlighting that the ban disproportionately affects trans youth who require life-saving medication. Although children can still receive puberty blockers for other medical conditions, approximately 491 individuals on the waiting list for gender dysphoria treatment may face significant delays. The Australian Human Rights Commission is expected to engage with the state government regarding these concerns.
AU
All Australia News ->