Decades-Long Mystery: Woman Missing Since 1981 Resurfaces in Phoenix
In a new episode of Investigation Discovery's series "The Curious Case Of...", the perplexing case of Mary Louise Day will be revisited, 42 years after her disappearance when she was just 13. Mary went missing from her family's home in Seaside, California, in 1981, leading to a lengthy investigation that suggested she was murdered. However, in November 2003, a woman claiming to be Mary showed up in Phoenix, Arizona, raising questions about her identity.
Mary's sister, Sherrie Calgaro, who was only 10 at the time of her sister's disappearance, expressed skepticism that the woman police stopped was actually Mary. The family had faced an unstable childhood, shifting among foster homes until returning to their birth mother, Charlotte, who was married to a military man during the time of Mary's disappearance.
According to investigators, tensions escalated the night Mary went missing, with reports suggesting potential violence from the stepfather, William Houle. Following her disappearance, cadaver dogs indicated the presence of a child's shoe in the family's backyard, but no body was found.
The episode titled "The Girl Who Died Twice" features insights from Sherrie and investigators involved in the case. As authorities conducted inquiries, "Phoenix Mary" became a focal point of speculation and investigation, prompting a quest for truth that remains unresolved. The episode is set to air on Monday, January 20, at 10 p.m. ET on ID.
Weekly Newsletter
News summary by melangenews