Court Rules Elephants Are Not People, Rejects Bid to Relocate Zoo Animals
A Colorado court has dismissed a legal attempt by an animal rights group to relocate five elephants from Cheyenne Mountain Zoo to a sanctuary, ruling that the animals do not possess the same rights as humans. The case centered on the elephants—Missy, Kimba, Lucky, LouLou, and Jambo—who the Nonhuman Rights Project (NRP) claimed were being unjustly imprisoned.
The Colorado Supreme Court concluded in a unanimous 6-0 decision that the state’s habeas corpus protections apply only to humans, stating that an "elephant is not a person," regardless of their cognitive or emotional abilities. This ruling upholds a prior district court decision that denied the NRP's petition, which argued the elephants were emotionally complex and suffering from trauma, brain damage, and chronic stress due to their captivity.
Following the ruling, Cheyenne Mountain Zoo defended its care of the elephants, labeling the NRP's lawsuit as "frivolous" and accusing the organization of misusing court resources for fundraising purposes. The zoo emphasized their commitment to the well-being of the elephants.
The NRP responded to the court's decision by expressing disappointment, asserting that it perpetuates an injustice whereby non-human animals are denied the rights of liberty. They acknowledged that challenges in their advocacy efforts are common when confronting established norms. This ruling follows another unsuccessful attempt by the NRP to secure the release of an elephant named Happy from a New York zoo on similar grounds.
Weekly Newsletter
News summary by melangenews